What’s really in your dog’s food? Inside the pet food industry with Clayton Payne

Ep 36. What’s really in your dog’s food? Inside the pet food industry with Clayton Payne

Most of us hand over our dog's dinner without a second thought, but what's really in that bag, and does it actually matter?

Welcome to The Yappy Hour, powered by Yappily!

In this episode, Nathan sits down with Clayton Payne, pet industry veteran, Chief Commercial Officer of The Bug Factory, and host of Pet Business Disruptors, for a refreshingly honest look behind the scenes of the pet food world.

From growing up in his parents’ pet shop to building a wholesale business for 22 years and now farming insects as a sustainable protein source, Clayton has seen every corner of this industry. Whether you’re a curious dog guardian, a raw feeding convert, or someone just trying to do better by your dog, this conversation is packed with practical, no-nonsense insight. Pull up a chair, this one’s a good one.

What You’ll Learn in This Episode:

✅ Why where you buy your dog’s food says more than you might think, and what the difference really is between a supermarket, a pet shop, and a raw food retailer

✅ How dog food is actually made, from formulation and manufacturing to packaging and getting it on shelves

✅ Why the raw food market has grown from less than half a percent to around 10% of the UK market, and what’s driving it

✅ What to actually look for on a dog food label (and what words to ignore entirely)

✅ The two big myths Clayton wants busted: mixing raw and kibble, and feeding the same protein every day

✅ What “natural,” “wholesome,” and “sustainable” actually mean on packaging. Spoiler: not much ✅ Where the pet industry is headed, and why mushroom-based supplements might be the next big thing

Key Takeaways:

  • If meat isn’t the first ingredient, put it back on the shelf. There’s usually something better in the same price range
  • You don’t have to overhaul everything at once. Even small additions like bone broth or pumpkin powder alongside kibble can make a real difference
  • Don’t just take your vet’s word on nutrition. They’re generalists, not nutritionists, and there are brilliant specialist resources out there
  • Variety of proteins matters. You wouldn’t eat the same meal every night, and neither should your dog

Thanks for tuning in! Let’s celebrate the joy and challenges of dog parenting together, because we’re all here for the dogs.

Connect with Clayton Payne

Pet Business Disruptors Facebook page

Pet Business Disruptors on Apple podcasts

Pet Business Disruptors on Youtube

Clayton Payne on LinkedIn

Connect with Nathan and Yappily

Connect with Nathan

Nathan Dunleavy website

Yappily Facebook

Yappily Instagram

Are you a compassionate Dog Pro?

If you’re a behaviourist, dog trainer, dog walker, house sitter, vet, home dog boarder, daycare provider or groomer, and you believe in kind, ethical care, we’d love for you to list your business on our directory!

To celebrate the launch of The Yappy Podcast we have a special code for you which gives 50% off a premium listing! sign up below to receive your code which you can then use at checkout.

Podcast launch code

The Yappy Hour Podcast is available anywhere you listen:

Listen on Spotify

Listen on Apple Podcasts

Listen on Amazon

Watch on YouTube

and we’d love for you to leave us a review!

Yappily - your Local Pet Service search hero. Quickly find accredited, qualified, and compassionate service providers near you!

Episodes

Woof with us!

Get updates on new services, special offers, and dog friendly activities in your area, straight to your inbox!

General sign up goes to group 'newsletter list'

Comments

  • No comments yet.
  • Add a comment

    Leave a Replay

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Click edit button to change this text. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit